“There’s No Secret to Selling a Novel”
Posted on Oct. 15, 2023 / Subscribe 0
Love at 350°, my debut novel with The Dial Press, published on Tuesday, October 10. I can barely believe it!
It’s been more than two years since I started writing this romantic comedy about an avid home baker who becomes a contestant on a TV baking competition and catches the eye of the show’s notoriously ruthless celebrity judge. At Dial, I am incredibly fortunate to have a phenomenal marketing and PR team to promote it through their reader-focused channels. (After years of working in communications and marketing, I’m thrilled to be a client for a change!)
I’m often asked, “What’s the secret to selling a novel?” I hate to tell you: there is no secret … because what publishers want is ever-changing and unpredictable. Still, you can improve your chances if you know how to navigate the submission process. Here’s what I’ve learned.
Prep your manuscript
First things first: your novel must be finished and print-ready. Have a few people whose writing you respect read the whole thing and offer their feedback. Whether you take their advice or not, this will help you revise and refine your story.
Pro tip: If copy editing is not your forte, consider hiring a professional. That level of polish sets you apart.
Research publishers and literary agents
You need to know which publishers buy your kind of story and whether you need an agent to approach them. Here are some ways to find them:
- Look up the publishers of books in the same genre as yours. Also read the acknowledgements, because the author usually thanks their agent. Look them up, too.
- Do an online search for literary agencies that represent your genre. On those sites, learn which of their agents are taking new clients.
- Writer’s Digest is a well-respected resource for writers with info on literary agencies and publishers that may accept direct submissions (i.e., not through an agent).
- Some agencies will announce they’re accepting new clients, and some publishers will accept unrepresented authors from time to time. Follow them on Instagram and X for updates.
Pro tip: Never pay someone to represent you. Agents are paid a percentage (typically 15%) of the sale price of your book. If they ask for money up front, walk away.
Assemble your list of agents
- Review the agency’s submission rules: how much of your book they want to see, what genres they accept, how to format your manuscript, etc. Follow these instructions to the letter.
- The agents’ bios will include books they’ve repped. Get familiar enough with those titles to be able to refer to them in the query (see below).
- Some agents want you to submit to them exclusively, meaning you haven’t approached other agents at the same time. Keep that in mind.
Pro tip: If there’s more than one agent in an agency repping your kind of material, submit to the one with fewer books under their belt. Those agents are building their rosters and may be able to focus more on you, whereas a more established agent might have their hands full.
Write your query
A query is the pitch you’ll email to agents, introducing them to you and your book.
- Summarize your book in a couple of paragraphs. You don’t have to introduce every character or outline the whole plot; give them enough info to want to read more.
- To give agents a better idea of what your book is about, be ready to compare your story to other properties they may be familiar with. In my case, I talked about The Great British Bake Off as an inspiration for my baking-centric romance.
- Develop a logline, which boils down the book’s premise into a catchy sentence. For Love at 350°, the logline is: When two women meet as judge and contestant on the set of a TV baking competition, they must decide what they’re willing to risk for the ultimate prize. Take a look at New York Times’ bestseller list for more examples.
- Proofread the bejeezus out of the email copy, double-check that you followed all of the agency’s submission requirements, then hit send!
Pro tip: Writing publications like Writer’s Digest and The Writer offer templates and advice for queries. Don’t want to pay for a subscription? Contact your local library for access.
And then you wait …
Some agents respond to all queries; others only contact those they’re interested in. If you hear nothing, follow up four to six weeks after submission—and if they don’t reply, move on.
If they do respond, it’s rarely a done deal. They may want more material; they may have editing advice; they may say no for now but encourage you to stay in touch. Respond to their message as soon as possible, and be sure to thank them for their time and expertise.
In the meantime, keep getting feedback from other readers; keep polishing your manuscript; keep researching other agencies; keep an eye out for publishers welcoming non-represented material; keep reading books in your genre … and keep the faith.
Lisa Peers is a creative director at Jack Morton Worldwide and a PRSA Detroit Board member.




0 Comments